Best Honey Mustard Reviews | Top Picks 2019

Honey, and mustard. Who would have ever thought to combine the two? Whoever did, we’re so glad they did. The two completely different flavors complement each other perfectly. Honey mustard is a condiment that you’ll find in most kitchens. It adds lots of flavor to various dishes and can be used as a dipping sauce too. If you add oil to honey mustard, it makes a great salad dressing.

History of Honey Mustard

best honey mustard
Photo by Wikimedia / CC BY

Honey has been included in the human diet for almost as long as we’ve existed. You can find mentioning of honey in basically all recorded history of humans and food. Honey was definitely used way before mustard was. However, mustard has still been around in the human diet for thousands of years. Some mustard recipes go as far back as 42 A.D.

The reason people started adding honey to mustard was to simmer down the sharp and strong flavor that we know mustard sometimes comes with. It also adds a hint of sweetness. Each ingredient works to bring out the underlying flavors of the other.

Types of Honey Mustard

Many people don’t know this, but there are quite a few different types of honey mustard. This is because there are many varieties of both mustard and honey. Every culture will have a different version of honey mustard. Adding honey to mustard actually makes entire countries use mustard more than they normally would. For example, British mustard is stronger and sharper than some people are used to. Because of this, much of the population doesn’t use it. Once the honey is added, you’ll find people using it for everything from salad dressings to lamb marinades. The French have a very mild version of honey mustard. You’ll also find different variations of honey mustard in Korea, China, and Japan.

Now, let’s get started with listing the best honey mustards!

Top Picks Summary

  1. Billy Bee Original
  2. French’s Honey Mustard
  3. Heinz Honey Mustard
  4. Primal Kitchen – Honey Mustard Vinaigrette & Marinade
  5. Sir Kensington’s Honey Mustard
  6. Follow Your Heart Vegan Honey Mustard Salad Dressing
  7. Mrs Bridges Honey Mustard with Champagne
  8. 365 Everyday Value, Organic Honey Mustard
  9. Kraft Honey Mustard Dressing

Top 9 Best Honey Mustards Reviewed

Billy Bee Original


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

Billy Bee creates classic honey mustard that many people are familiar with. They use their own Billy Bee brand of honey to make this condiment. This is rare for companies and also something admirable about this brand. Billy Bee is known for making delicious Canadian honey, 100% sourced from local Canadian beekeepers. They don’t outsource their honey from other countries.

The source of their honey is always traced – it’s truly from flower to table. This guarantees a consistent taste and flavor throughout all their products. They’ve been delivering natural and delicious honey since 1958, so Billy Bee knows what they’re doing!

This Billy Bee mustard is full of flavor in every spoonful. This company recommends trying it as a dipping sauce for corn dogs, pretzels, or chicken nuggets. You can also substitute regular mustard with this for sandwiches. If you cook a lot of meats, you can brush this flavorful honey mustard over the meat (it works great on chicken) and bake as you normally would.

The ingredients are: water, sugar, dextrose, mustard seed, honey, vinegar, salt, modified tapioca starch, titanium dioxide (for color), spice, caramel color, garlic powder, yellow #5, natural flavor.

French’s Honey Mustard


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

The previous honey mustard that we discussed (Billy Bee) is a Canadian brand that is known worldwide. French’s mustard, on the other hand, is known as the best honey mustard in the United States. It uses #1 grade mustard seeds for the best taste, along with real honey.

This French mustard is recommended to use in wraps, dressings, dips, sandwiches, and so much more. For those who only eat Kosher food, you’re in luck because this  mustard is kosher certified. It’s also gluten-free, which is an appealing thing to those who are celiac but also those who simply watch their gluten intake.

French’s describes the flavor profile as the following: creamy, smooth, sweet, and tangy all at the same time. Talk about an explosion of flavors in your mouth!

This USA made honey mustard is proud to contain no high fructose corn syrup, which we all know isn’t the healthiest thing for us. The exact ingredients of this product are: distilled vinegar, water, sugar, #1 grade mustard seed, honey, salt, spices, carrot oleoresin (color) and garlic powder.

In case you’re wondering what carrot oleoresin is, it’s a totally natural form of coloring that’s made out of carrots. It provides the mustard with a distinct and unique yellow shade without any negative side effects. This is used in replacement of any artificial dyes or colorings. French’s honey mustard also doesn’t use any artificial flavors – no need when the taste of the product itself is sublime! Even people who don’t like mustard will enjoy this mustard.

Heinz Honey Mustard


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

Almost everyone that lives in a developed country is familiar with the Heinz brand. They make great ketchup, mustard, and relish. Even though most people know of this brand and regularly buy their products, many aren’t aware that they make a delicious honey mustard too.

Heinz has already created a delicious signature mustard, so that made it easier for them to create this specific condiment. They combined real honey with their mustard to produce this sweet yet tangy honey mustard. The sauce is bright yellow and can be used in any dish that you want. If you think a dish is lacking flavor but you aren’t 100% sure what to add – this can be your new go-to. The mustard seeds used are stone ground, and the honey is 100% real. All of the other ingredients in this bottle of honey mustard are completely natural as well.

The ingredients are as follows: distilled white vinegar, water, cane sugar, mustard seed, dark brown sugar, honey, salt, molasses, mustard flour, spices, natural flavor, and turmeric. Totally natural! Even the sweetener used (brown sugar) is one of the best they could have used. It’s better than white sugar, and also better than corn syrup, glucose, or any other sweetener.

There are a couple of ingredients in here that we haven’t seen many other companies include in honey mustard. Mustard flour, molasses, and turmeric are all very unique ingredients to use.

Mustard flour is also known as mustard powder. It’s simply the finely ground mustard seeds. Don’t be fooled by the term flour – mustard flour is completely gluten-free. Molasses is a great ingredient to use because it boosts the overall iron content of this sauce. For those who are anemic, molasses is a great thing to try and include more of in your diet. Finally, turmeric is known for being extremely healthy for you and anti-inflammatory.

The Heinz mustard sauce is great for your health. It’s fat-free and contains just 10 calories per serving, so it’s a great sauce for those who are trying to lose weight or simply watch their calories.

Primal Kitchen – Honey Mustard Vinaigrette & Marinade


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

Do you remember at the beginning of this article when we mentioned that honey mustard makes a great salad dressing and marinade? Well, instead of you having to worry about making that yourself, you can buy pre-made honey mustard products such as the above.

This specific one is both a vinaigrette and a marinade. Being able to only buy 1 product instead of 2 not only saves you money, but it also saves you time and space in your fridge as well. The brand that makes this product, Primal Kitchen, is well known amongst many health-conscious niches such as those who follow a paleo diet, for example.

This mustard vinaigrette contains of course honey and mustard, but also 100% pure avocado oil. All the rest of the ingredients in this condiment are completely natural as well, most ingredients actually being organic. The ingredients go as follows: Avocado Oil, Filtered Water, Organic Apple Cider Vinegar, Organic Stone Ground Mustard (Organic Apple Cider Vinegar, Organic Mustard Seed, Water, Salt, Organic Spices) Sea Salt, Organic Honey, and Organic Lemon Juice Concentrate. Wow! Talk about a clean list of ingredients. Anyone who is conscious of their health and what they put into their body on a daily basis will be drawn to this condiment.

The company recommends using this honey mustard vinaigrette with bitter greens or just straight up as a dipping sauce. Apparently, it goes especially well with radicchio, and their recommended recipe is honey mustard braised short ribs.

Rather than being high in saturated fats, this condiment is high in monounsaturated healthy fats that are derived from the 100% pure avocado oil. It doesn’t contain any of the typical GMO oils like canola, sunflower, or safflower oils. For those with gluten intolerances, it is certified gluten-free. This mustard is great for those following a paleo diet, and vegans who include honey in their diet can enjoy this tangy and sweet vinaigrette as well.

Sir Kensington’s Honey Mustard


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

If you’re looking for honey mustard made with extremely high-quality ingredients, this is the brand for you. Sir Kensington is known for making a few different types of mustard. They make dijon mustard, yellow mustard, spicy brown mustard, and honey mustard too. The Sir Kensington mustard is a favorite of many.

This company first perfected their mustard recipe. It’s so good that they hold the title of Mustard Championship Medalist. Not only are the ingredients in the honey mustard pure and high-quality, they’re also Non-GMO Project Certified. The fact that this company went out of their way to achieve that high standard truly shows how committed to their customers they are. On top of all that, the honey used in their  mustard is Fair Trade Organic. This means that the farmers who provided the honey were paid with a fair and equal wage.

If you eat a gluten-free diet, you’ll be glad to know that their honey mustard is certified gluten-free. It’s also paleo friendly and certified Kosher. With this being a natural product, there aren’t any artificial flavors or colorings. There also aren’t any preservatives because the vinegar naturally preserves this condiment. Sir Kensington has a saying that goes: “Our condiments are always in good taste, with good taste, for those with good taste.”

The exact ingredients of this mustard are: Water, Distilled Vinegar, Fair Trade Organic Honey, Mustard Seed, Fair Trade Organic Cane Sugar, Salt, Turmeric, Allspice, Cinnamon, Cloves, and Coriander. It’s definitely one of the purest honey mustards we’ve come across so far!

The Sir Kensington mustard comes in a squeeze bottle that needs to be refrigerated after opening. The 9 oz bottle contains around 51 servings, which is a lot! A serving size is 1 teaspoon, which contains only 10 calories. The mustard is also fat-free, so it’s great to use as a condiment for those who are following a low-fat and/or low-calorie diet.

Follow Your Heart Vegan Honey Mustard Salad Dressing


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

This is the first vegan honey mustard product we’ve included on this list. Most honey mustards only contain one ingredient that doesn’t make them vegan, and that ingredient is honey. Since honey comes from bees and not from plants, most vegans don’t consume it. This mustard uses other sweeteners such as brown rice syrup and agave to mimic the honey flavor.

This mustard salad dressing is a perishable item so it needs to be refrigerated. You can use it as recommended (as a salad dressing) or you can use it as a dipping sauce or a spread for sandwiches.

The ingredient list in this product are lengthier than other honey mustards, mostly because of all the alternatives needed to replicate the flavor of honey. The ingredients are: Vegenaise (Expeller-Pressed Canola Oil, Filtered Water, Brown Rice Syrup, Apple Cider Vinegar, Soy Protein, Sea Salt, Mustard Flour, Lemon Juice Concentrate), Vegan Honey Alternative (Brown Rice Syrup, Agave Nectar, Maple Syrup, Natural Flavors), Filtered Water, Expeller-Pressed Canola Oil, Prepared Mustard (Vinegar, Water, Mustard Seeds, Salt, Turmeric, Spices, Natural Flavors), White Wine Vinegar, Organic Dijon Mustard* (Apple Cider Vinegar*, Water, Mustard Seed*, Salt, Spices*), Onion, Whole Mustard Seeds, Sea Salt, Xanthan Gum, Spices. *Certified Organic CONTAINS: Soy

This mustard is certified gluten-free, certified vegan, and dairy-free. Most of the ingredients are organic which is great for those who are health conscious. Overall, it’s a great condiment to have in your fridge, whether you’re vegan or not.

Mrs Bridges Honey Mustard with Champagne


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

Mrs. Bridges’ honey mustard with champagne is the first international brand of honey mustard that we’ve featured on this list. It’s a product of Scotland. More specifically, Arbroath Scotland. Even though this is an international brand, it’s enjoyed by customers all across the world.

This mustard is unique in the way that it comes in a small, round and wider glass jar. It’s truly a signature jar shape for this brand. There’s also a mop cap on each jar which is very traditional, and a bow tied around it. If you’re giving this as a gift, it already comes wrapped for you!

All of this mustard made by Mrs. Bridges is made in small batches, which ensures consistent quality and taste throughout. The recipes she uses are all traditional British ones, and so are her methods of cooking these recipes.

Since this is a handmade item, there are no artificial flavors or colorings added. There are also no unnatural preservatives. The full list of ingredients are: Water, White Wine Vinegar, MUSTARD Flour (24%), Honey (13%), Salt, MUSTARD Bran (3%), Spices, Champagne (with Marc de Champagne). It’s very interesting and helpful that Mrs. Bridges includes the percentage of each ingredient used, because not many manufacturers do this. Even though, we, as consumers, find it useful and helpful.

Basically, there are three main flavors to this Mrs. Bridges mustard – the smooth taste of traditional mustard, the sweet touch of honey, and the added luxury that comes with the Champagne in this condiment. It truly makes you feel like you’re eating the classiest and highest-quality honey mustard that exists.

The Mrs. Bridges mustard is gluten-free, paleo, and vegetarian. It’s not suitable for those on a vegan diet due to the honey.

365 Everyday Value, Organic Honey Mustard


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

In case you weren’t aware, 365 Everyday Value is a Whole Foods Market brand. They make an abundance of organic products that they sell at various Whole Foods locations, and one of them is organic honey mustard.

What separates this mustard from many others on the market is the fact that it’s made with organic apple cider vinegar rather than standard white vinegar. This gives it a unique flavor and kick that you might not find in other honey mustards. Like many other honey mustards on this list, this is a fat-free mustard. Just like the name indicates, it’s certified organic. It’s also certified Kosher and certified Vegetarian, but it’s not vegan.

The ingredients of this mustard are extremely pure and high quality. They are: Organic distilled vinegar, organic apple cider vinegar, water, organic mustard seed, organic sugar, organic honey, sea salt, organic paprika, citric acid, organic turmeric, organic spices. As you can see, there aren’t any artificial flavors or colorings. Even the fact that the spices are organic is admirable. The only preservative used in this mustard is citric acid, which is a form of vitamin C and completely natural and good for us.

Kraft Honey Mustard Dressing


[CLICK ON IMAGE FOR THE PRICE]

If you’re a fan of sweet foods, this mustard is for you. Kraft is a brand that basically all of us know and most people use on a daily basis. They make delicious ketchup and mustard that is a staple in most households. Their honey mustard dressing is nothing short of amazing. It’s made in Canada without any artificial flavors or colorings.

It’s great as a salad dressing as the name indicates, but many also love using it as a dip for fries. The only complaint people seem to have about this mustard is that it’s slightly higher in calories per serving compared to other honey mustards, but that’s only because it has a bit of added oil to make it more of a “dressing” than a sauce. Overall, it’s still delicious!

Health Benefits of Honey

Now that you’re aware of some of the best honey mustard brands, it might be nice to know the health benefits of this special condiment that you’re eating. We will discuss both the health attributes of honey and mustard separately, starting with honey.

As you might know, honey is one of, if not the oldest sweetener on earth. Unlike other sweeteners such as sugar, honey is actually good for you! We know it’s hard to believe that something sweet and yummy in syrup form can be good for us, but it is.

Here are just a few of the many health benefits of honey:

  1. Helps to prevent heart disease
  2. Helps to prevent various forms of cancer
  3. Full of flavonoids and antioxidants
  4. Boosts your immune system
  5. Reduces ulcers
  6. Anti-bacterial
  7. Ant-fungal
  8. Reduces coughing and throat irritations
  9. Helps regulate blood sugar levels
  10. Probiotic
  11. Aids in reducing acne

Health Benefits of Mustard

Mustard has been around for as long as honey has. Many people don’t consider mustard as a superfood or health food, but it really does fall under that category.

Here are some of mustard’s benefits:

  1. Helps to relieve muscle pains
  2. Can prevent cancer
  3. Helps to manage diabetes
  4. Helps to detoxify the body
  5. Repels poison
  6. Beneficial for heart health
  7. Lowers cholesterol levels
  8. Lowers the risk of bladder cancer
  9. Relieves symptoms of psoriasis
  10. Has a healing effect on nerves

Conclusion

We hope that after reading this article, you are more informed about the options you have and everything that goes into creating it. We know how difficult of a decision it can be deciding on what brand to purchase, so we hope that this article made the decision an easier one. We tried our best to narrow your selection down to the very best tasting honey mustards out there.

You may also like:

Best Fish Sauce Reviews
Best Pork Rind Reviews
Best Oyster Sauce Reviews